A Positive Alternative: Why Not Join Thakura Bhaktivinoda's Original Guru Parampara? (1)
A Positive Alternative:
How
the Parampara Began
At the end of his /Bhagavatarka marici mala//,
Bhaktvinoda writes the following guru vandana:
punaraya
mone hailo sriguru carane
aktajna
haile bhakti sadhibo kemone
lajja
tyaji likhi eve tadiya agyai
aparadha
yadi hoy ksama mahasaya
vipina
vihari prabhu mama prabhu bora
sri
vamsivadan-ananda vamsa sasadhara
sei
prabhupader ajna sire dhori
bhagavat
slokasvada nirantara kori//I
"Let me remember once again my gurudeva's lotus
feet; for without showing gratitude how can I execute bhakti sadhana? Let me
submit that I am writing under his order. My Sri Gurudeva is Vipina vihari who
has appeared like a bright full moon within Vamsivadan-ananda Thakura's guru
parampara. Thus, in respectfully holding my Prabhupada's merciful order over my
head, I constantly relish the /Bhagavatam's slokas."
The
Parampara's Glories
We can also discover that
there are uncountable manjari lineages descending from various nitya siddha
parshadas of Caitanya Mahaprabhu. Yet because He desired that we follow in the
Six Goswami's footsteps (who are all manjaris) each parampara is a manjari
parampara.
[Back in the 80's when I
was taking siksa from Madanmohan das Baba at Radhakund, I got the chance (or
received the privilege we should say) to see the siddha pranali charts
of a number of bhaktas belonging to other paramparas. One came from Advaita
parivar, a few were from other branches coming from Nityananda Prabhu, I saw
another which descended from Gadadhar Pandita, and others that came from
Srinivasa Acarya and Dhananjaya Pandita. Though I noticed that Madanmohan
Baba's siddha manjari parampara begins from Narottam das Thakura.
After examining the charts
and learning some things about these other parivaras, however, I must confess
that we feel the most happy (and satisfied) with Thakura Bhaktivinoda's lineage
which is truly unique and special. One reason is that amongst the Vraja gopis
Ananga Manjari's position is special, and another is that the parivara includes
Vamsivadan and Vishnupriya at the beginning. Hence when Srimati Vishnupriya
leads the Sampradaya as its foremost Acarya, that means a lot. We shall attempt
to explain more about this in Part 3.]
Here is Thakura
Bhaktivinoda's guru parampara in Vraja with siddha pranali (the manjari
names of each member):
1) Sri Jahnava
Thakurani, Srimati Ananga Manjari
2) Sri
Ramai Thakura, Srimati Ratna Manjari
3) Sri
Rajavallabha Goswami, Srimati Rāsa Manjari
4) Sri
Keshavacandra Goswami, Srimati Kanaka Manjari
5) Sri
Rudresvara Goswami, Srimati Rati Manjari
6) Sri
Dayarama Goswami, Srimati Dana Manjari
7) Sri
Mahesvari Goswamini, Srimati Madhu Manjari
8) Sri
Gunamanjari Goswamini, Srimati Guna Manjari
9) Sri
Ramanani Goswamini, Srimati Rasa Manjari
10)
Sri Jajnesvara
Goswami, Srimati Juthi Manjari
11)
Sri Vipina vihari
Goswami, Srimati Vilasa Manjari
12)
Sri Bhaktivinoda
Thakura, Srimati Kamal Manjari
Now someone might comment: "What is the big deal;
what are we supposed to do with this list?"
gopi anugata vina aisvarjya
jnane
bhajileo nahi paya
vrajendra nandane
"By neglecting to follow in the sakhis footsteps and worshiping on the vidhi marga, we can never attain Krsna in Vrindavan." — C.C. 2.8.229
Srimati
Ananga Manjari's Unique Position
Unlike other gopis Ananga Manjari is isvari tattva
(the form of Balarama and Radha's sakti combined), Radha's younger sister, and
a yuthesvari (sakhi leader) who enjoys sambhoga pastimes with Krsna.
Thus the manjaris in her group receive something special that we can imbibe
from Jahanava's teachings to Ramai:
sancaribhava anurupa krsna
dite piriti
adhika prapustha kore
bhavollasa rati
"Our manjari bhava (bhavollasa rati) will become
more nourished when the sancari bhava (temporary mellow) of Krsna
piriti (romantic love for Krsna) awakens within it." — Murali vilasa, Chapter 6
Though here we find Caitanya caritamrita
confirming the same siddhanta in context with Radha's magnanimity:
yadyapi
sakhira krsna sangame nahi mona
tatapi
radhika jatne koraye sangam
nana
chole krsna preri sangam koraya
atma-sukha-sanga
haite koti sukhapaya
anyonye
visuddha prema kore rasa pusta
ta sabar
prema dekhe krsna hoy tusta
"Although the sakhis and manjaris don't try to
enjoy Krsna themselves (as they focus on Radha's sangam with him) Radha will
carefully arrange their Krsna sangam. In fact Radha will make sure by various
means that Krsna gets to enjoy with them. Then Radha experiences a pleasure a
million times greater than her own sangam with Krsna. This pure and magnanimous
behavior of Radha and her sakhis nourishes their prema and makes Krsna very
happy." — C.C. 2.8.211-13
So,
in Ananga Manjari's group the special reward that occasionally happens is that
her manjaris (by her kripa) get to unite with Krsna. Now we may ask: In our
Vaisnava world today how has the trend come about that we (as manjaris) should never
ever think about the idea of mixing with Krsna? Doesn't this sound a bit
unnatural, for after seeing Krsna's superlative beauty who would fail to become
attracted? We shall address this matter further, in a later part of this essay.
Concerning one's ekadasa bhava initiation,
Bhaktivinoda says the following in Harinama cintamani's last chapter:
gurudeva sisyer svabhavik
pravrtti pariksa koriya jakhon dekhiben je tini srngara
raser adhikari bate,
takhon tahake sriradhar yuthe srilalitar gane sadhiker
siddha manjari svarupa
avagata koriyadeben, sadhaker ekadasa bhava o sadhya
gato astakala lila
dekhaiya deben, sadhaker je ghare janma grahan koriya je
patir
sange tahar bibaha hoy taha boliya deben. vedadharma parityaga koro to
sriyuthesvari
palyadasi bhava o tahar astakala nitya seva dekhaiya deben
sadhaker
se bhave barma koriya smaran dasay pravesa koriben.
ihai
sadhaker vraja gopi janna.
"The guru will test the disciple to see if he or
she is eligible for srngara rasa sadhana. If so, he will assign the sadhika's
siddha manjari svarupa within Radha's yutha in the group of Lalita (or
in the group of another one of Radha's asta sakhis). The guru will then award ekadasa
bhava (the eleven items that make up the sadhika's siddha manjari svarupa such
as name, form, quality and seva, etc.) and explain what her nitya seva will be
in Radha Krsna's astakala lila. The guru will even tell in which gopa and
gopi's home the sadhika dasi will take birth, and to which gopa she will
be married. But after transgressing Vedic dharma the sadhika manjari will
become the palyadasi (fostered maidservant) of her yuthesvari
Radha to carry out her astakala nitya seva. When the disciple accepts these
items from the guru he may begin in smaran sadhana, for she will take birth as
a Vraja gopi in this way."
This is simply wonderful! Because when the guru awards
ekadasa bhava to us, won't this eliminate so much unnecessary guesswork
about who we are in the spiritual world? Then by the guru and guru parampara's
grace the sadhika manjari will have everything she needs to begin smaran
sadhana seriously. And this can even lead to her attaining siddhi in a short
time.
In noting that his son Lalita prasada was faithful
towards Vipin vihari Goswami, Bhaktivinoda appreciated this and duly initiated
him with siddha pranali and ekadesa bhava. Hence Lalita prasada
Thakura preserves the ancient tradition that his father maintained.
But on the other hand, Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati
Thakur could not appreciate Vipina vihari, and went on to create his own
sampradaya.
In seeing this outcome, however, the Radhakund
Vaisnava community doesn't support Bhaktisiddhanta's new sampradaya. For they
contend that to take up raganuga sadhana properly one must receive diska from
an unbroken manjari parampara that descends from an eternal associate of
Caitanya Mahaprabhu.
Now what can be said about this? It appears that
Bhaktisiddhanta was more concerned about preaching – and he became very
successful at this by introducing tridandi sannyasa. For his sannyasi followers
and their supporters have grown to such an extent that they outnumber all of
the other Vaisnava groups today. So on one hand they have done great work to
spread the Hare Krsna Sankirtana movement far and wide to every corner of the
world – a task that the Radhakund Vaisnava samaja could never do.
Now it will be interesting to compare these two
different approaches to Krsna bhakti sadhana.
Sannyasa
Versus Siddha Pranali
As we can discover both a positive and negative side
to the sannyasa ashram, let us first try and examine its positive side.
If a sannyasi is ideal, what will he be thinking when
he comes to a new town or place; won't he be pondering about how he can preach
and make new devotees? He will first try to set up a centre, invite people,
give lectures, go out on preaching engagements, and hold Sunday feasts, etc. In
this way he will gather a group together, engage the people, preach to them and
initiate the more serious followers he has made. Then he may go to another
place to take up the same work.
The dress or get-up is conducive too, because the wall of saffron cloth he wears stands out in the crowd and allows him to more easily influence the people around him. In a sannyasi's garb then there have become countless devotees (when considered together) who have created a huge worldwide Vaisnava following. One setback to this lifestyle, however, is that such devotees almost never gather the time nor the interest to inquire about raganuga bhakti sadhana.
The Pitfalls
On the coin's other side, however, the sannyasi ashram
is quite dangerous, as it is very difficult for a sannyasi to remain totally
aloof from sex desire. Thus the Bhagavatam reminds us that this ashram
should never be attempted in Kaliyuga for a good reason: For we have seen time
and time again many famous and charismatic sannyasis who have amassed a great
following, made numerous preaching centres, and inherited lots of fame, fall
prey to sex desire. Thus they prove themselves to be hypocrites, cause havoc
amongst their disciples, and end up losing everything.
<center><b>Siddha
Pranali//b
But the person who by Krsna's mercy or the mercy of
his devotee develops lobha (greed) to take siddha pranali and ekadasa
bhava initiation has a different nature and mentality. Such devotees are
very rare, however, because in our modern Vaisnava institutions today the topic
is avoided, and if it is discussed it will usually be done to discourage
devotees from taking to this path.
But this is a shame we must contend because the
preaching of raga marga bhakti forms the main reason for Gauranga's appearing
in our world, as Caitanya caritamrita affirms:
ye lagi
avatara kahi sei mula karon
premarasa
niryasa korite asvadana
raganuga
bhakti loke korite pracarana
rasika
sekhar krsna param karuna
ei dui hetu
koite icchar udgama//i
"Now let me speak about the main reason for Gauranga's
advent: 1) He comes to relish the very essence of (Vraja) prema rasa, and by so
doing 2) he preaches raganuga bhakti to the people. Because Krsna is the
greatest rasika and very merciful he comes as Gauranga to fulfill these two
desires." — C.C.
1.4.14-16
After
reading these invaluable teachings can we say that ISKCON and the Gaudiya Math
are missing the point? Because after forming large worldwide institutions that
focus on preaching alone (which is the external reason for Mahaprabhu's advent)
they overlook the important necessity to take up and preach raganuga bhakti
sadhana, which is the main internal reason for the Lord's coming.
Now
a relevant question arises: Who are we by the way; what is our eternal
identity?
To
answer, the siddha pranali and ekadasa bhava system tells us
exactly who we are in Krsna lila. Although reversedly, the sannyasa ashram
attaches us to an identity whom we are not. Caitanya Mahaprabhu testifies to
this in Caitanya caritamrita:
naham vipro naca narapatirapi vaisyo na sudro
naham
varni naca grha patirno vanastha yatirba
kintu
pradyon nikhila paramananda purnamritabdher
gopibharttuh
padakamalayor dasanudasa//i
"I am not a brahmina, a raja, a vaisya, nor a
sudra. Neither am I a brahmacari, a grhastha, a vanaprastha, nor a sannyasi.
What I am, however, is the dasanudasa of the real form of all universal nectar
and bliss – Gopijana Vallabha Sri Krsna."
Now what does it boil down to then, isn't the sannyasa
ashram nothing more than an upadhi (external bodily designation)? For it
has nothing to do with our eternal relationship with Krsna. Hence Rupa Goswami
reminds us that we will have to give up all upadhis:
<center><i>sarvopadhi vinirmuktam
tatporatvena nirmalam
hrskesea hrsikesa sevnam
bhaktirucyate//i
"Suddha bhakti can be executed after we give up
all upadhis (external designations) and engage our senses purely in
Krsna's seva."
— Bhaktirasamrita sindhu 1.1.12
So
just as a policeman or an army man have their specific uniforms to assist them
in their jobs, a Krsna conscious preacher may take to the sannyasa ashram to
assist his preaching mission in the dress of a sannyasi. But we should know
that this dress is pratikula (unfavorable) for developing our internal
relationship with Krsna.
<center><b>Narottama das Thakur's Advice//B
<center><i>rager bhajan path, kahi
eve abhimata
loka veda sara ei vani
sakhir anuga haiya, vraje
siddha deha paiya
sei bhave jurabe
parani//I
"Our
Vaisnava Mahajanas and the sastras unanimously agree that the raganuga path is
the most essential. Thus by following in the sakhis' footsteps and receiving a
siddha gopi svarupa in Vraja all of our desires can be fulfilled."
—
Premabhakti candrika
Lila Smaran and Manasi Seva
Now
what will a raganuga bhakta contemplate when he sits down to do japa? Instead
of thinking about anything of our world, his focus will be internal – as his
mind enters the transcendental realm of Radha Krsna's astakala pastimes in
Goloka Vrindaban.
- 1) an
ideal secluded place,
- 2) a
firm vow, and
- 3) ideal
sadhu sanga.
An
Example
Vilasa then leads us to Citra's bower on Radhakund's
eastern side, for her gurudevi Juthi Manjari is Citra's palyadasi. But
Juthi appears to be thinking about something else as she quickly leads us to Campaklata's
bower on Radhakund's southern shore. For her gurudevi Rasa Manjari resides here
in the kunja named Ananga. In seeing Rasa Manjari one could easily be misled,
however, because she looks almost like Ananga Manjari herself – as her age,
dress and bodily color are the same as hers.
"Come, let's go to meet our pranesvari
Ananga," says Ratna, "she will be waiting for us." Arriving at
Radhakund's northern shore, Ratna points to a huge 16-petaled red lotus that
basks in the sun's rays right in the Kund's center.
"Look! There is Ananga Manjari's Anangambuja
Kunja," she exclaims. As I begin to wonder how we are going to get there,
out of nowhere Ratna starts crossing a hidden crystal bridge that leads us over
the water! If Ratna had not uncovered it, we would have missed seeing the
bridge, as it blends so nicely with the surrounding environment.
Arriving at Anangambuja Kunja, we are all struck with
wonder again, because the huge red lotus that we saw from the opposite shore is
actually only a small part of what we now see – for there are limitless keli
kunjas that surround the central padma mandira. Thus I marvel at the wonder, as
this must surely be the arrangement of Yogamaya herself.
When Ratna leads us to Ananga Manjari's baitaka
(sitting room) she is not there; thus we all start looking around. But there
she is at the ghata, Ananga Manjari is just coming out of the water after
bathing.
[Now we need to explain how Yogamaya arranges these
lilas. Because it is amazing that every sakhi and manjari gets to see the lila
from her own perspective. And thus everyone can perceive that it is
"they" who are serving in a direct and leading role. This is
Yogamaya's expertise in that every gopi gets the chance to fulfill her
innermost desires.]
Seeing Ananga Manjari stepping out of the kund in her
dripping wet srana vastra, my gurudevi Lata requests me: "Ja! Ja! (quickly
go!) Since you are expert in dressing, you may now dress and decorate your
Pranesvari in that moonstone pavilion over there."
Offering a million pranams (within my mind) to my
gurudevi's lotus feet, I approach Ananga Manjari. But upon seeing me she
surprisingly exclaims: "O Paramā! How nice that you have
come; will you quickly dress me because my didi and Madhava will be
arriving here very soon."
O my! Tears come to my eyes and I am swept off my feet
– for how could Ananga Manjari recognize me with such affection? Although my
name is Parama sukhi, she intimately addresses me with her own chosen nickname
"Paramā" instead!
With our assistants Premalata, Priyalata, Citralata
and Carulata we have Ananga Manjari expertly dressed and decorated in no time
(it was the kalpa-vrksas who supplied all of the ingredients). In fact
she looks so ravishing that one might guess that Ananga (Cupid) did the job
himself. All the while Ananga is very talkative. She is gossiping with me in
such an intimate way that I get the feeling that she considers me her very dear
and intimate companion. Then when we hold a full length mirror before her,
Ananga gasps in seeing her beauty, and comments, "Aha! This will be (no
doubt) an excellent offering for my Pranaballabha Shyam."
"Come with me," Ananga then says,
"let's go to the yoga pitha mandira." As we proceed along we soon
arrive at a quaint little temple that is sparkling with gems. But aho! As we
enter the mandira's inside it is limitlessly expansive! There are countless
gopis inside whose bodily luster appears to shimmer like the effulgence of
millions of suns – yet their darshan is more cooling to the eyes than a million
moons!
In the yoga pitha's center – there stands Radha beside
her beloved Krsna. But when she sees Ananga Manjari enter, Radha starts waving
her hands to call her over. And when Ananga arrives before her didi, Radha
affectionately requests that she stand on her right side.
I am simply amazed and swept off my feet as I watch
everything beside the door. The yoga-pitha formation's majestic splendor is
matchless! In the thousand-petaled lotus' whorl or karnika (centerpiece)
stand Ananga Manjari, Krsna and Radha. Then closest to them stand Radha's
renowned asta manjaris headed by Rupa. Next in the lotus' first eight petals
stand Radha's leading Asta sakhis headed by Lalita. Then comes another circle
of sakhis in the lotus's next set of petals. And beyond them there are
countless other sakhis who all belong to Radha's yutha (group).
My mind then ponders: "Just a minute ago Ananga
Manjari was intimately speaking with me as though I were amongst her closest
sakhi friends. But now as I see that she is more dear to Radha than all of her
other sakhis and manjaris, I am simply struck with wonder! O how have I become
so fortunate to have the privilege of serving her lotus feet?"
"Hey dasi! Ai! Ai! (Come, come!),"
says Lata. "Let's go to the lotus karnika to begin worshiping
Ananga Manjari with Krsna and Radha. Then we shall worship all of Radha's
leading sakhis and manjaris."
After the yoga pitha puja when everyone steps out of
the mandira a number of exciting pastimes will begin. Govinda lilamrita
tells that there will be a vasanta holi, jhulan, madhu pan,
rati keli, jala keli, vana bhojan, sayana, pasa
khela and Surya puja.
So as we have been performing lila smaran and manasi
seva in our mentally conceived manjari svarupa these pastimes can each be
meditated upon in the company of our siddha manjari parampara. For they will
factually be there to guide us. Hence Thakura Bhaktivinoda's manjari parivar
forms a ladder that will lead us right up to Ananga Manjari and Radha Krsna in
Goloka Vrindaban's nitya lila. By such contemplation then, it will some day all
fructify to become a direct living experience in the spiritual world. This is
because in raganuga sadhana the process and the goal are very similar, as
Narottama das Thakura assures us in Prema bhakti candrika:
<center><i>sadhane bhavibe jaha,
siddha dehe pabe taha, raga pathe ei sei upaya
sadhane
je dhan cai, siddha dehe taha pai pakka pakka matro se vicara//I
"Whatever we contemplate during sadhana, that we
will attain in the siddha deha – for this is the method on the raga marga. It
is just a question of our sadhan bhakti maturing to the stage of prema."
In Part 2 we look forward to writing about the glories
of Vamisvadan Thakura. Then in Part 3 we shall tell something about Vishupriya
devi's astakala lilas with Gaurasundar in Goloka Navadvipa.
Because these two leading acaryas have a lot to offer
us, two separate parts will be required – just to say a little bit.
Comments
“The treasure I desire (desired Siddha Deha) as a practitioner I will get when I attain my spiritual body (realized Siddha Deha); it is just a question of being ripe or unripe. The ripe stage is the stage of pure devotion (prema-bhakti), and the unripe stage is the stage of practice (raganuga-sadhana-bhakti). That is the essential truth about devotional principles.”
https://bhakti-tattva.blogspot.com/2015/09/esta-e-chave-para-o-sucesso-na-vida.html
Your names and the names of your guru, the son of Bhaktivinod Thakur.
And regarding, what kind of relationship Bhaktivinode Thakur shared with Bipin Vihari Gosvami, it is quite evident by how vehemently the current followers of Bipin Vihari criticize Bhaktivinode Thakur, trying to rob him off from his spiritual status of being a siddha, perfected devotee of the Lord.
Clearly, for a thinking person without bias understands Bhaktivinode Thakur disagreed with the opinions of Bipin Vihari Gosvami from the loads of information and articles available.
Srila Sarasawati Thakur's line from Bhaktivinode Thakur is siksha-based and that is how parampara comes down. Like from one major scientist to the next while ignoring the not so significant acharyas that may be in between the succession.
Jaya Nitai!
My feelings about sampradāya and paramparā have indeed evolved over the years. I have had the good fortune to experience the vestiges of the pre-Iskcon, pre-Gaudiya Math setting, and it is precisely in order to experience it that I left Iskcon and the Gaudiya Math.
I say that with all humility because in fact my respect for Prabhupada and his movement, even in its present forms, knows no bounds.
Someone wrote to me the famous phrase, punar mushiko bhava, which I thought was nice. I mean it is true, here I am a little mouse again, and again. So when I see all that I gave up in leaving ISKCON, in not accepting the responsibility that Prabhupada had bestowed on me, I acted outside my adhikara.
At any rate, I probably would have ended up something like Jayadwaita Maharaj, which mind you I don't think is a particularly bad place to be, all things considered. I always thought of myself as more the six Goswamis type, feeble a sadhaka as I may have been.
Spending the year round half naked, rising early to escape the heat, reading in order to memorize. That was the kind of lazy bhakti that I caught hold of. It no doubt requires a very high adhikara and if you fall, it is certainly terrible to become a mere mouse again.
Of course, the key verse is...
nāhaṁ tu sakhyo bhajato’pi jantūn
bhajāmy amīṣām anuvṛtti-vṛttaye |
yathādhano labdha-dhane vinaṣṭe
tac-cintayānyan nibhṛto na veda ||
My beloved friends, I do not reciprocate with those who love Me in a strictly mechanical way. [They are] just like a poor man who loses the wealth he has gained, and alone, dwells on nothing else. (10.32.20)
O friends, I am different in that I do not simply respond mechanically to the devotion of those who worship me. Rather, I wish to see their love increase [until], like the poor man who has lost a fortune and in secret can think of nothing else, [they can think of nothing but Me].” (BhP 10.32.20)
O My friends! I do not reciprocate the love of those who even love Me so that they can think of Me continuously. They are like people who got wealth and then suddenly lost it, Such people think only of the wealth and nothing else. (10.32.20) SN KS 161
O My friends, I do not always reciprocate the love of even those devotees who love Me. I behave in this way so that they can fully become absorbed in thoughts of Me, just like a poor person who loses a treasure after obtaining it becomes engrossed in thoughts of the wealth and knows nothing else. BBT
Of course, I am far too egotistic to allow myself to sink into too much humility. I secretly think of nothing else, but it is always accompanied by feelings of amazement and gratitude for the experiences I have had, and for whatever tiny accomplishments I have had in my life due to the grace of my gurus and of Gauranga and Giridhari. Not enough yet to swamp my vile nature, but there you go. Life is what it is and I am not finished yet.
Jai Sri Radhe.